Developed Countries
The yen has been the worst-performing currency in the developed FX space this year. Unlike the euro area or the US, the Japanese economy remains under siege from the pandemic. The number of new COVID-19 cases is at the highest level per capita in developed…
UK retail sales declined unexpectedly in May. The headline number fell 1.4% m/m following a 9.2% m/m jump in April, disappointing expectations of a deceleration to 1.5%. Similarly, sales excluding auto fuel were down 2.1% m/m from 9.1% m/m, versus an…
Dear Client, Next week, instead of our regular report, we will be sending you a Special Report from BCA Research’s MacroQuant tactical global asset allocation team. Titled “MacroQuant: A Quantitative Solution For Forecasting Macro-Driven Financial Trends,” this white paper will discuss the purpose, coverage, and methodology of the MacroQuant model. I hope you will find the report insightful. We will be back the following week with the GIS Quarterly Strategy Outlook, where we will explore the major trends that are set to drive financial markets for the rest of 2021 and beyond. We will also be holding a webcast on Thursday, July 8 at 10:00 AM EDT (3:00 PM BST, 4:00 PM CEST, 10:00 PM HKT) to discuss the outlook. Best regards, Peter Berezin Chief Global Strategist Highlights Although the Fed delivered a hawkish surprise on Wednesday, monetary policy is likely to remain highly accommodative for the foreseeable future. We continue to see high US inflation as a long-term risk rather than a short-term problem. Outside of a few industries, wage inflation remains well contained. In those industries suffering from labor shortages, the expiration of emergency unemployment benefits, increased immigration, and the opening up of schools should replenish labor supply. Bottlenecks in the global supply chain are starting to ease. Many key input prices have already rolled over, suggesting that producer price inflation has peaked and is heading down. A slowdown in Chinese credit growth could weigh on metals prices during the summer months, which would further temper inflationary pressures. We are downgrading our view on US TIPS from overweight to neutral. Owning bank shares is a cheaper inflation hedge. Look Who’s Talking The Fed jolted markets on Wednesday after the FOMC signaled it may raise rates twice in 2023. Back in March, the Fed projected no hikes until 2024 (Chart 1). Chart 1Fed Forecasts Converge Toward Market Expectations Seven of 18 committee members expected lift-off as early as 2022, up from four in March. Only five participants expected the Fed to start raising rates in 2024 or later, down from 11 previously. The Fed acknowledged recent upward inflation surprises by lifting its forecast of core PCE inflation to 3.4% for 2021 compared with the March projection of 2.4%. These forecast revisions bring the Fed closer to market expectations, although the latter are proving to be a moving target. Going into the FOMC meeting, the OIS curve was pricing in 85 bps of rate tightening by the end of 2023. At present, the market is pricing in about 105 bps of tightening. At his press conference, Chair Powell acknowledged that FOMC members had discussed scaling back asset purchases. “You can think of this meeting as the ‘talking about talking about’ meeting,” he said. A rate hike in 2023 would imply the start of tapering early next year. The key question for investors is whether this week’s FOMC meeting marks the first of many hawkish surprises from the Fed. We do not think it does. As Chair Powell himself noted, the dot-plot is “not a great forecaster of future rate moves,” before adding that “Lift-off is well into the future.” Ultimately, a major monetary tightening cycle would require that inflation remain stubbornly high. As we discuss below, while there are good reasons to think that the US economy will eventually overheat, the current bout of inflation is indeed likely to be “transitory.” This implies that bond yields are unlikely to rise into restrictive territory anytime soon, which should provide continued support to stocks. Inflation: A Long-Term Risk Rather Than A Short-Term Problem Chart 2Globalization Plateaued More Than A Decade Ago There are plenty of reasons to worry that US inflation will eventually move persistently higher. As we discussed in a recent report, many of the structural factors that have suppressed inflation over the past 40 years are reversing direction: Globalization is in retreat: The ratio of global trade-to-manufacturing output has been flat for over a decade (Chart 2). Looking out, the ratio could even decline as more companies shift production back home in order to gain greater control over unruly global supply chains. Baby boomers are leaving the labor force en masse. As a group, baby boomers control more than half of US wealth (Chart 3). They will continue to run down their wealth once they retire. However, since they will no longer be working, they will no longer contribute to national output. Continued spending against a backdrop of diminished production could be inflationary. Chart 3Baby Boomers Have Accumulated A Lot Of Wealth Despite a pandemic-induced bounce, underlying productivity growth remains disappointing (Chart 4). Slow productivity growth could cause aggregate supply to fall short of aggregate demand. Social stability is in peril, as exemplified by the recent dramatic increase in the US homicide rate. In the past, social instability and higher inflation have gone hand in hand (Chart 5). Chart 4Trend Productivity Growth Has Been Disappointing Chart 5Historically, Social Unrest And Higher Inflation Move In Lock-Step Perhaps most importantly, policymakers are aiming to run the economy hot. A tight labor market will lift wage growth (Chart 6). Not only could higher wage growth push up inflation through the usual “cost-push” channel, but by boosting labor’s share of income, a tight labor market could spur aggregate demand. Despite these structural inflationary forces, history suggests that it will take a while – perhaps another two-to-four years – for the US economy to overheat to the point that persistently higher inflation becomes a serious risk. Consider the case of the 1960s. While the labor market reached its full employment level in 1962, it was not until 1966 – when the unemployment rate was a full two percentage points below NAIRU – that inflation finally took off (Chart 7). Chart 6A Tight Labor Market Eventually Bolsters Wages Chart 7Inflation Started Accelerating Quickly Only When Unemployment Reached Very Low Levels In The 1960s In May, 4.4% fewer Americans were employed than in January 2020 (Chart 8). The employment-to-population ratio for prime-aged workers stood at 77.1%, 3.4 percentage points below its pre-pandemic level (Chart 9). Chart 8US Employment Still More Than 4% Below Pre-Pandemic Levels Chart 9Prime-Age Employment-To-Population Ratio Remains Below Pre-Pandemic Levels A Labor Market Puzzle Admittedly, if one were to ask most companies if they were finding it easy to hire suitable workers, one would hear a resounding “no.” According to the National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB), 48% of firms reported difficulty in filling vacant positions in May, the highest share in the 46-year history of the survey (Chart 10). Chart 10US Labor Market Shortages (I) Chart 11US Labor Market Shortages (II) Nationwide, the job openings rate reached a record high of 6% in April, up from 4.5% in January 2020. The share of workers quitting their jobs voluntarily – a measure of worker confidence – also hit a record of 2.7% (Chart 11). How can we reconcile the apparent tightness in the labor market with the fact that employment is still well below where it was at the outset of the pandemic? Four explanations stand out. First, unemployment benefits remain extremely generous. For most low-wage workers, benefits exceed the pay they received while employed. It is not surprising that labor shortages have been most pronounced in sectors such as leisure and hospitality where average wages are relatively low (Chart 12). The good news for struggling firms is that the disincentive to working will largely evaporate by September when enhanced unemployment benefits expire. Chart 12Labor Scarcity Prevalent In Low-Wage Sectors Chart 13School Closures Have Curbed Labor Supply Second, lingering fears of the virus and ongoing school closures continue to depress labor force participation. Chart 13 shows that participation rates have recovered less for mothers with young children than for other demographic groups. This problem will also fade away by the fall when schools reopen. Third, the number of foreign workers coming to the US fell dramatically during the pandemic. State Department data show that visas dropped by 88% in the nine months between April and December of last year compared to the same period in 2019 (Chart 14). President Biden revoked President Trump’s visa ban in February, which should pave the way for renewed migration to the US. Chart 14US Migrant Worker Supply Is Depressed Chart 15The Pandemic Accelerated Early Retirement Fourth, about 1.5 million more workers retired during the pandemic than one would have expected based on the pre-pandemic trend (Chart 15). Most of these workers were near retirement age anyway. Thus, there will likely be a decline in new retirements over the next couple of years before the baby boomer exodus described earlier in this report resumes in earnest. Other Input Prices Set To Ease Just as labor shortages in a number of industries will ease later this year, some of the bottlenecks gripping the global supply chain should also diminish. The prices of various key inputs – ranging from lumber, steel, soybeans, corn, to DRAM prices – have rolled over (Chart 16). This suggests that producer price inflation for manufactured goods, which hit a multi-decade high of 13.5% in May – has peaked and is heading lower. Chart 16Input Prices Have Rolled Over The jump in prices largely reflected one-off pandemic effects. For example, rental car companies, desperate to raise cash at the start of the pandemic, liquidated part of their fleets. Now that the US economy is reopening, they have found themselves short of vehicles. With fewer rental vehicles hitting the used car market, households flush with cash, and new vehicle production constrained by the global semiconductor shortage, both new and used car prices have soared. Vehicle prices have essentially moved sideways since the mid-1990s (Chart 17). Thus, it is doubtful that the recent surge in prices represents a structural break. More likely, prices will come down as supply increases. According to a recent report from Goldman Sachs, auto production schedules already imply an almost complete return to January output levels in June. Chart 17Vehicle Prices Have Essentially Moved Sideways Since The Mid-1990s Chart 18Rebounding Pandemic-Affected Services Prices Are Pushing Up Overall CPI As Chart 18 shows, more than half of the increase in consumer prices in April and May can be explained by higher vehicle prices, along with a rebound in pandemic-affected service prices (airfares, hotels, and event admissions). Outside those sectors, the level of the CPI remains below its pre-pandemic trend (Chart 19). Chart 19Unwinding Of "Base Effects" Chart 20"Supercore" Inflation Measures Remain Well Contained More refined measures of underlying inflation such as the trimmed-mean CPI, median CPI, and sticky price CPI are all running well below their official core CPI counterpart (Chart 20). While certain components of the CPI basket, such as residential rental payments, are likely to exhibit higher inflation in the months ahead, others such as vehicle and food prices will see lower inflation, and perhaps even outright deflation. Slower Chinese Credit Growth Should Temper Commodity Inflation Chart 21Chinese Credit Growth And Metal Prices Move Together Chinese credit growth and base metals prices are strongly correlated (Chart 21). We do not expect the Chinese authorities to embark on a new deleveraging campaign. Credit growth has already fallen back to 11%, which is close to the prior bottom reached in late-2018. Nevertheless, to the extent that changes in Chinese credit growth affect commodity prices with a lag of about six months, metals prices could struggle to maintain altitude over the summer months. China’s plan to release metal reserves into the market could further dampen prices. We remain short the global copper ETF (COPX) relative to the global energy ETF (IXC) in our trade recommendations. The trade is up 18.4% since we initiated on May 27, 2021. We will close this trade if it reaches our profit target of 30%. Bank Shares Are A Better Hedge Against Inflation Than TIPS We have been overweight TIPS in our view matrix. However, with 5-year/5-year forward breakevens trading near pre-pandemic levels, any near-term upside for inflation expectations is limited (Chart 22). As such, we are downgrading TIPS from overweight to neutral in our fixed-income recommendations. Investors looking to hedge inflation risk should consider bank shares. Our baseline view is that the 10-year Treasury yield will rise to about 1.9% by the end of the year. If inflation fails to come down as fast as we anticipate, bond yields would increase even more than that. Chart 23 shows that banks almost always outperform the S&P 500 when bond yields are rising. Chart 22Limited Near-Term Upside For Inflation Expectations Chart 23Bank Shares Thrive in A Rising Yield Environment Banks are also cheap. US banks trade at 12.2-times forward earnings compared with 21.9-times for the S&P 500. Non-US banks trade at 10-times forward earnings compared to 16.4-times for the MSCI ACW ex-US index. Finally, we like gold as a long-term inflation hedge. We would go long gold in our structural trade recommendations if the price were to fall to $1700/ounce. Peter Berezin Chief Global Strategist pberezin@bcaresearch.com Global Investment Strategy View Matrix Special Trade Recommendations Current MacroQuant Model Scores
Weekly Performance Update For the week ending Thu Jun 17, 2021 The Market Monitor displays the trailing 1-quarter performance of strategies based around the BCA Score. For each region, we construct an equal-weighted, monthly rebalanced portfolio consisting of the top 3 stocks per sector and compare it with the regional benchmark. For each portfolio, we show the weekly performance of individual holdings in the Top Contributors/Detractors table. In addition, the Top Prospects table shows the holdings that currently have the highest BCA Score within the portfolio. For more details, click the region headers below to be redirected to the full historical backtest for the strategy. BCA US Portfolio Total Weekly Return BCA US Portfolio S&P500 TRI -2.34% -0.37% Top Contributors WAT:US IT:US PSA:US KOF:US MPLX:US Weekly Return 12 bps 4 bps 2 bps 1 bps 0 bps Top Detractors TX:US SCCO:US STX:US LPX:US AN:US Weekly Return -38 bps -33 bps -27 bps -14 bps -13 bps Top Prospects TX:US BRK.A:US ESGR:US ANAT:US UHAL:US BCA Score 99.09% 98.99% 97.29% 96.86% 96.54% BCA Canada Portfolio Total Weekly Return BCA Canada Portfolio S&P/TSX TRI -0.74% 0.54% Top Contributors TOY:CA CSU:CA CPX:CA TCN:CA DSG:CA Weekly Return 14 bps 11 bps 9 bps 9 bps 8 bps Top Detractors CS:CA PXT:CA TCL.A:CA LNR:CA IMO:CA Weekly Return -43 bps -29 bps -19 bps -19 bps -18 bps Top Prospects CS:CA LNF:CA IFP:CA RUS:CA CFP:CA BCA Score 99.79% 98.75% 98.48% 98.39% 96.94% BCA UK Portfolio Total Weekly Return BCA UK Portfolio FTSE 100 TRI -0.22% 0.94% Top Contributors OXIG:GB POLR:GB CVSG:GB AAF:GB AGRO:GB Weekly Return 21 bps 16 bps 15 bps 10 bps 8 bps Top Detractors FDEV:GB HSBK:GB SVST:GB DRX:GB VVO:GB Weekly Return -36 bps -14 bps -13 bps -11 bps -10 bps Top Prospects SVST:GB GLTR:GB NLMK:GB RMG:GB BPCR:GB BCA Score 99.77% 98.61% 98.37% 97.91% 96.67% BCA Eurozone Portfolio Total Weekly Return BCA EMU Portfolio MSCI EMU TRI 0.12% 1.27% Top Contributors STR:AT PHA:FR AOF:DE GTT:FR EDNR:IT Weekly Return 22 bps 19 bps 13 bps 12 bps 8 bps Top Detractors SOLV:BE CEM:IT MMT:FR TKA:AT MS:IT Weekly Return -11 bps -8 bps -8 bps -7 bps -7 bps Top Prospects STR:AT SOLV:BE POST:AT CNV:FR BB:FR BCA Score 99.02% 98.56% 98.44% 97.93% 97.52% BCA Japan Portfolio Total Weekly Return BCA Japan Portfolio TOPIX TRI 0.90% 0.35% Top Contributors 2791:JP 4966:JP 3132:JP 6676:JP 7994:JP Weekly Return 32 bps 31 bps 27 bps 19 bps 18 bps Top Detractors 8117:JP 8850:JP 3291:JP 8595:JP 6345:JP Weekly Return -14 bps -13 bps -12 bps -11 bps -10 bps Top Prospects 5930:JP 3291:JP 4966:JP 9436:JP 7994:JP BCA Score 99.48% 98.95% 98.66% 98.34% 98.32% BCA Hong Kong Portfolio Total Weekly Return BCA Hong Kong Portfolio Hang Seng TRI 0.79% -0.61% Top Contributors 990:HK 3600:HK 857:HK 215:HK 1919:HK Weekly Return 58 bps 51 bps 21 bps 18 bps 15 bps Top Detractors 1258:HK 2877:HK 2768:HK 323:HK 743:HK Weekly Return -25 bps -19 bps -15 bps -12 bps -11 bps Top Prospects 990:HK 1606:HK 2232:HK 86:HK 116:HK BCA Score 98.85% 98.22% 97.78% 97.60% 97.38% BCA Australia Portfolio Total Weekly Return BCA Australia Portfolio S&P/ASX All Ord. TRI -0.99% 0.56% Top Contributors JLG:AU FLN:AU NEW:AU PL8:AU ELD:AU Weekly Return 24 bps 21 bps 16 bps 8 bps 8 bps Top Detractors PDN:AU GRR:AU CIA:AU SRV:AU CAJ:AU Weekly Return -50 bps -23 bps -18 bps -17 bps -13 bps Top Prospects GRR:AU PIC:AU CIA:AU BFG:AU BLX:AU BCA Score 98.90% 98.01% 97.03% 96.38% 96.21%
Based on the reaction of financial markets, Wednesday’s FOMC meeting produced an unquestionably hawkish surprise for financial markets. US Treasuries sold off, the US dollar strengthened, and gold fell. However, equity moves were significantly more muted. The…
Highlights Oil demand expectations remain high. Realized demand continues to disappoint. This means OPEC 2.0's production-management strategy – i.e., keeping the level of supply below demand – will continue to dictate oil-price levels. US producers will remain focused on consolidation via M&A and on returning capital to shareholders, in line with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia's (KSA) expectation. Going forward, shale producers will focus on protecting and growing profit margins. The durability of OPEC 2.0's tactical advantage arising from its enormous spare capacity – ~ 7mm b/d – is difficult to gauge: Tightening global oil markets now in anticipation of Iran's return as a bona fide exporter benefits producers globally, and could accelerate the return of US shales if that return is delayed or re-opening boosts demand more than expected. We are raising our average Brent forecast for 2021 to $66.50 vs. $63/bbl earlier, with 2H21 prices averaging $70/bbl. We are moving our 2022 and 2023 forecasts up slightly to $74 and $81/bbl (Chart of the Week). WTI will trade $2-$3/bbl lower. We remain long the S&P GSCI Dynamic Roll Index ETF (COMT) and the S&P GSCI, expecting tight supply-demand balances to further steepen backwardations in forward curves. Feature While the forecasted rebound in global oil demand continues to drive expectations for higher prices, it is the production discipline of OPEC 2.0 and capital discipline imposed on US shale producers that has and will continue to super-charge the recovery of prices. Continued monetary accommodation and fiscal stimulus notwithstanding, realized global oil demand has mostly flatlined at ~ 96mm b/d following its surge in February, as uncertainty over COVID-19 containment keeps governments hesitant about reopening their economies too quickly. Stronger demand in Asia, led by China, has been offset by weaker demand in India and Japan, where COVID-19 remains a deterrent to re-opening and recovery. The recovery in DM demand generally stalled over this period even as vaccine availability increased (Chart 2). Chart of the WeekOPEC 2.0 Comfortable With Higher Prices Chart 2Global Demand Recovery Stalled That likely will change in 2H21, but it is not a given: The UK, which has been among the world leaders in COVID-19 containment and vaccinations, delayed its full reopening by a month – to July 19 – in an effort to gain more time to bolster its efforts against the Delta variant first identified in India. In the US, New York state lifted all COVID-19-induced restrictions and fully re-opened this week. Still, even in the US, unintended inventory accumulation in the gasoline market – just as the summer driving season should be kicking into high gear – suggests consumers remain cautious (Chart 3). Chart 3Unintended Inventory Accumulation in US Gasoline Market We continue to expect the re-opening of the US and Europe (including the UK) will boost DM demand in 2H21, and wider vaccine availability will boost EM oil demand later in the year and in 2022. For all of 2021, we have lifted our demand-growth estimate slightly to 5.3mm b/d from 5.2mm b/d last month. We expect global demand to grow 4.1mm b/d next year and 1.6mm b/d in 2023. Our 2021 estimates are in line with those of the US EIA and the IEA. OPEC is more bullish on demand recovery this year, expecting growth of 6mm b/d. We continue to believe the risk on the demand side remains to the upside; however, given continued uncertainty around global COVID-19 containment, we remain circumspect. Supply-Side Discipline Drives Oil Prices OPEC 2.0 remains committed to its production-management strategy that is keeping the level of supply below demand. Compliance with production cuts in May reportedly was at 115%, following a 114% rate in April.1 Core OPEC 2.0 – i.e., states with the capacity to increase production – is holding ~ 7mm b/d of spare capacity, according to the IEA, which will allow it to continue to perform its role as the dominant supplier in our modeling (Chart 4). Earlier this year, KSA's Energy Minister Abdulaziz bin Salman correctly recognized the turn in the market that likely ensures OPEC 2.0's dominance for the foreseeable future – i.e., the shift in focus of the US shale-oil producers from production for the sake of production to profitability.2 This is a trend that has been apparent for years as capital markets all but abandoned US shale-oil producers. Chart 4OPEC 2.0 Remains Dominant Producers outside OPEC 2.0 – what we refer to as the "price-taking cohort" – have prioritized shareholder interests as a result of this market pressure, and remain focused on sometimes-forced consolidation via M&A, which we have been expecting.3 The significance of this evolution of shale-oil production is difficult to overstate, particularly as the survivors of this consolidation will be firms with strong balance sheets and a focus on profitability, as is the case with any well-run manufacturing firm. We also expect large producers to opportunistically shed production assets to reduce their carbon footprints, so as to come into compliance with court-ordered emission reductions and shareholder demands to reduce pollution.4 With the oil majors like Shell, Equinor and Oxy divesting themselves of shale properties, production increasingly will be in the hands of firms driven by profitability.5 We expect US shale-oil production to end the year at 9.86mm b/d and to average 9.57mm b/d next year; however, as the shales become the marginal global supply, production could become more volatile (Chart 5). The consolidation of US production also will alter the profitability of firms continuing to operate in the shales. We expect breakeven costs to fall as acquired production by stronger firms results in high-grading of assets – only the most profitable will be produced given market-pricing dynamics – while less profitable acreage will be mothballed until prices support development(Chart 6). Chart 5US Producers Focus On Profitability Chart 6Shale Breakevens Likely Fall As Consolidation Picks Up Supply-Demand Balances Tightening The current round of M&A consolidation and OPEC 2.0's continued discipline lead us to expect continued tightening of global oil supply-demand balances this year and next (Chart 7). This will allow inventories to continue to draw, which will keep forward oil curves backwardated (Chart 8). Chart 7Supply-Demand Balances Will Continue To Tighten Chart 8Tighter Markets, Lower Stocks The critical factor here will be OPEC 2.0's continued calibration of supply in line with realized demand and the return of Iran as a bona fide exporter, which we expect later this year. OPEC 2.0's restoration of ~ 2mm b/d of supply will be done by the beginning of 3Q21, when we expect Iran to begin restoring production and visible exports (i.e., in addition to its under-the-radar sales presently). The return of Iranian supply – and a possible increase in Libyan output – will present some timing difficulties for OPEC 2.0's overall strategy, but they will be short-lived. We continue to monitor output to assess the evolution of balances (Table 1). Table 1BCA Global Oil Supply - Demand Balances (MMb/d, Base Case Balances) Investment Implications Oil demand will increase over the course of 2H21, as vaccines become more widely distributed globally, and the massive fiscal and monetary stimulus deployed worldwide kicks economic activity into high gear. On the supply side, markets will tighten on the back of continued restraint until Iranian barrels return to the market. The balance of risk is to the upside, particularly if the US and Iran are unable to agree terms that restore Iran as a bona fide exporter. In that case, the market tightening now under way will result in sharply higher prices. That said, realized demand growth has stalled over the past three months, which can be seen in unintended inventory accumulation in the US gasoline markets just as the summer driving season opens. We are raising our average Brent forecast for 2021 to $66.50 vs. $63/bbl earlier, with 2H21 prices averaging $70/bbl. We are moving our 2022 and 2023 forecasts up slightly as well to $74 and $81/bbl (Chart of the Week). WTI will trade $2-$3/bbl lower. We remain long the S&P GSCI Dynamic Roll Index ETF (COMT) and the S&P GSCI, expecting tight supply-demand balances to further steepen backwardations in forward curves. The big risk, as highlighted above, remains an acceleration of COVID-19 infections, hospitalizations and deaths, which force governments to delay re-opening or impose localized lockdowns once again. In this regard, KSA's strategy of calibrating its output to realized – vice forecasted – demand likely will remain in place. Robert P. Ryan Chief Commodity & Energy Strategist rryan@bcaresearch.com Ashwin Shyam Research Associate Commodity & Energy Strategy ashwin.shyam@bcaresearch.com Commodities Round-Up Energy: Bullish China's refinery throughput surged 4.4% to 14.3mm b/d in May, a record high that surpassed November 2020's previous record of 14.26mm b/d, according to S&P Platts Global. The increased runs were not unexpected, and were largely accounted for by state-owned refiners, which operated at 80% of capacity after coming out of turnaround season. Turnarounds will fully end in July. In addition, taxes on niche refined-product imports are due to increase, which will bolster refinery margins as inventories are worked down. China's domestic crude oil production was just slightly more than 4mm b/d. Base Metals: Bullish China's Standing Committee approved the release an undisclosed amount of its copper, aluminum and zinc stockpiles via an auction process in the near future, according to reuters.com. The government disclosed its intent on the website of National Food and Strategic Reserves Administration on Wednesday; however, specifics of the auction – volumes and auction schedule, in particular – were not disclosed. Prices had fallen ~ 9% from recent record highs in the lead-up to the announcement, which we flagged last month.6 Prices rallied from lows close to $4.34/lb on the COMEX Wednesday (Chart 9). Precious Metals: Bullish After a worse-than-expected US employment report, we do not expect the Federal Reserve to lift nominal interest rates in Wednesday’s Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) meeting. The Fed will only raise rates once the US economy reaches a level consistent with its definition of "maximum employment." Wednesday’s interest rate decision will be crucial to gold prices. If the Fed does not mention asset tapering or an interest-rate hike, citing current inflation as a transitory phenomenon, gold demand and prices will rise. On the other hand, if the Fed indicates an interest rate hike sooner than the previously stated 2024, this will weigh on gold prices (Chart 10). Ags/Softs: Neutral As of June 13, 96% of the US corn crop had emerged vs. the five-year average of 91%, according to the USDA. 68% of the crop was rated in good to excellent condition, slightly below the five-year average. In the bean market, 94% of the crop was planted as of 13 June, vs. the five-year average of 88%. The Department reported 86% of the crop had emerged vs. the five-year average of 74%. According to the USDA, 52% of the bean crop was in good-to-excellent condition vs the five-year average of 72%. Chart 9 Chart 10 Footnotes 1 Please see OPEC+ complies with 115% of agreed oil curbs in May - source published by reuters.com on June 11, 2021. 2 Please see Saudis raise U.S. and Asian crude prices for April delivery published by worldoil.com on March 8, 2021. 3 Please see US shale consolidation continues as Independence scoops up Contango Oil & Gas published by S&P Global Platts on June 8, 2021. 4 We discuss this in A Perfect Energy Storm On The Way, published on June 3, 2021. Climate activism will become increasingly important to the evolution of oil and natural gas production, and likely will lead to greater concentration of supply in the hands of OPEC 2.0 and privately held producers that do not answer to shareholders. 5 Please see Interest in Shell's Permian assets seen as a bellwether for shale demand published by reuters.com on June 15, 2021. 6 Please see Less Metal, More Jawboning, which we published on May 27, 2021. It is available at ces.bcaresearch.com. Investment Views and Themes Strategic Recommendations Tactical Trades Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Trades Closed in 2021 Summary of Closed Trades
Highlights New variants of SARS-Cov-2 will create new waves of infection, the inflation bubble is bursting, and massive slack in the US labour market will keep US inflation structurally subdued. The coming years will be defined by a trifecta of surging productivity, massive slack in the labour market, and ultra-low inflation. Overweight US T-bonds both tactically and structurally. Equity investors should overweight growth versus value… …overweight defensives versus cyclicals… …overweight the US versus the euro area… …and overweight DM versus EM, both tactically and structurally. Tactically underweight US REITS. Tactically overweight Nike versus L’Oréal. Feature Chart of the WeekThe Global Pandemic Is Still In Flow The UK will have to wait for its ‘freedom day.’ Lifting the remaining pandemic-related restrictions has been postponed because a new and more vaccine-resistant ‘delta’ variant of the virus is threatening to unleash a third wave of UK infections. The UK experience is important because it was the first major developed economy to roll out its mass vaccination program. Thereby, the UK experience could be the harbinger of things to come in other major economies like the US and the euro area. Vaccines Against RNA Viruses Are Not Highly Effective The general public and financial markets have high expectations that mass vaccination programs can banish Covid forever. Such expectations are unrealistic, just as it is unrealistic to expect vaccinations to banish the flu forever. It is unrealistic to expect vaccinations to banish Covid forever. Covid, the flu, and measles are all diseases caused by ‘RNA viruses.’ The defining characteristic of RNA viruses is their poor proofreading ability during replication, resulting in high rates of mutation. The resulting variant strains make RNA viruses highly effective at evading vaccinations. As the Journal of Immunology Research puts it:1 “No vaccine or specific treatment is available for many of these RNA viruses and some of the available vaccines and treatments are not highly effective.” Measles is an exception because its virus is ‘antigenically monotypic.’ The spike proteins (antigens) that the measles virus uses to infect a cell cannot mutate even slightly without breaking. However, the SARS-CoV-2 spike proteins can mutate and still infect. This we know because the virus has already evolved several infectious variants – including the latest delta variant – with increasing abilities to evade the current spike-based vaccines (Figure I-1). Figure I-1How Variants Of SARS-CoV-2 Evade Spike-Based Vaccines SARS-Cov-2 doesn’t care who it infects or in which country they live. Sadly, the pandemic has claimed more fatalities in the first half of 2021 than in the whole of 2020 (Chart of the Week). And the virus will continue to mutate liberally given that its reproduction rate is still close to 1 (Chart I-2). Chart I-2The Reproduction Rate Is Still Close To 1 Crucially, the mutations of the virus that evade vaccinations are the ones that are more likely to spread and become the new dominant strains. After the delta variant will come the epsilon variant, the zeta variant, the eta variant… and so on until we run out of Greek alphabet. In which case, should we just adopt the same strategy for Covid as we use for the seasonal flu – remove all pandemic-related restrictions, while offering booster vaccinations to the most medically vulnerable once or twice a year? There are two problems with this strategy: First, it could still overwhelm our healthcare systems during surges in demand. This we know because a bad flu season, by itself, was already pushing some healthcare systems to the limit. There is very little spare capacity to cope with additional demand. Second, unlike the flu, Covid appears to have long-term sequelae, colloquially called ‘long Covid’ with unknown chronic damage to health. As the Lancet points out: “Long-term sequelae of Covid-19 are unknown… we owe good answers on the long-term consequences of the disease to our patients and healthcare providers” Without these answers, policymakers cannot adopt the same strategy for Covid as for the flu. So yes, we can certainly offer vaccinations to the most medically vulnerable once or twice a year. But managing infections will also require non-pharmaceutical interventions, dialled up and down based on the severity of future waves of infection. A Productivity Super-Boom Is Coming Periodic non-pharmaceutical interventions which include restrictions to national and international movement will be around for much longer than the general public and financial markets expect. This will solidify a more remote way of working, shopping, interacting, and doing business. The good news is that this will create the mother of all productivity booms. Productivity tends to surge after every recession. This is because the period immediately after a recession is when the economy experiences the most intensive clearing out of dead wood, restructuring of capital and labour, and absorption of new technologies and ways of working. The pandemic has forced nearly every company and every worker to adopt new technologies and ways of working and living. But whereas most recessions upend one or two sectors of the economy, the pandemic has upended all sectors – forcing nearly every company and every worker to adopt new technologies and ways of working and living. This will make the pandemic productivity boom a super-boom unlike anything experienced in recent history (Chart I-3). Chart I-3The Pandemic Productivity Boom Will Be A Super-Boom The unfortunate corollary of this productivity super-boom is that the pace of absorption of the excess unemployed and inactive will be slower, meaning that it will take a long time to reach the goal of ‘full employment’ (Chart I-4). Chart I-4It Will Take A Long Time To Reach 'Full Employment' In the US, the Federal Reserve is acutely aware of this. As Jay Powell has pointed out: “It’s going to be a different economy. We’ve been hearing a lot from companies looking at deploying better technology and perhaps fewer people, including in some of the services industries that have been employing a lot of people. It seems quite likely that a number of the people who had those service sector jobs will struggle to find the same job, and may need time to find work” Without full employment, it will be difficult to maintain US inflation at or above the Fed’s 2 percent target. The transmission mechanism is that the (permanent) unemployment rate establishes the ability to pay rent. Thereby, it is the main driver of ‘rent of shelter’, which comprises almost half of the core consumer price index. Empirically, unless rent of shelter inflation gets to 3 percent and remains there, it will be very difficult for core inflation to remain at over 2 percent (Chart I-5 and Chart I-6). For reference, rent of shelter inflation is now running well short of 3 percent, at 2.2 percent. Chart I-5Full Employment Is Needed To Lift Rent Inflation To 3 Percent... Chart I-6...And Rent Inflation At 3 Percent Is Needed To Keep Core Inflation At 2 Percent In a nutshell, the coming years will be defined by a trifecta of surging productivity, massive slack in the labour market, and ultra-low inflation. Overweight Growth, And Overweight The US Given that new variants of the virus will create new waves of infection, that The Inflation Bubble Will Burst, and that the massive slack in the labour market will keep inflation structurally subdued, investors should own US T-bonds both tactically and structurally. There is massive slack in the US labour market. Furthermore, The Pareto Principle Of Investment tells us that if you get the direction of the bond yield right, you will get your whole investment strategy right. Declining bond yields boost growth stocks. This is because the ‘net present value’ of cashflows that are weighted deep into the future are highly leveraged to a falling discount rate. In addition, the productivity super-boom will be facilitated by technology and new economy sectors. As such, equity investors should avoid value, and steer towards growth, both tactically and structurally (Chart I-7). This extends to overweighting defensives versus cyclicals, overweighting the growth-heavy US versus the value-heavy euro area, and so on. In effect, all these positions are just one massive correlated trade (Charts I-8-Chart I-11). Chart I-7Structurally Overweight Growth Versus Value Chart I-8Correlated Trades: Bond Price, Growth Versus Value... Chart I-9...Tech Versus ##br##Market... Chart I-10...Defensive Versus Cyclical... Chart I-11...And US Versus Euro Area These sector preferences also imply an overweight to developed markets (DM) versus emerging markets (EM). Tactically Underweight US REITS, And Tactically Overweight Nike Versus L’Oréal Finally, and corroborating the preceding sections, the rally in ‘reopening plays’ has become fractally fragile. One way to play this tactically is to underweight US REITS (Chart I-12). Chart I-12'Reopening Plays' Are Fractally Fragile: US REITS But our preferred tactical expression is to overweight Nike versus L’Oréal (Chart I-13), setting the profit target and symmetrical stop-loss at 9 percent. Chart I-13'Reopening Plays' Are Fractally Fragile: L'Oreal Versus Nike Dhaval Joshi Chief Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Journal of Immunology Research, Volume 218: Immune Responses to RNA Viruses, by Elias A. Said Fractal Trading System Fractal Trades 6-Month Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Fractal Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Equity Market Performance Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields - Euro Area Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields - Europe Ex Euro Area Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields - Asia Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields - Other Developed Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations

